News Summary

Jurupa Valley High School is at the center of controversy as high school senior AB Hernandez’s participation as a transgender athlete has sparked outrage among rival schools. Several schools, including Orange Vista, Rim of the World, and Riverside Poly, have forfeited matches in protest. While supporters advocate for Hernandez’s right to compete under California law, opponents raise concerns about fairness in sports. The ongoing debate touches upon broader issues of equality and representation, with national attention now focused on the situation.

Controversy Erupts Over Transgender Athlete Participation in Jurupa Valley

In the bustling city of Jurupa Valley, the local high school has become a hotbed of controversy surrounding student athlete AB Hernandez, a 17-year-old senior who’s making quite the name for herself. Known for her incredible talent, Hernandez has snagged multiple medals in the state track and field championships, winning first place in both the high jump and triple jump while finishing a remarkable second in the long jump. This impressive performance not only secured her a spot among the best in the state but also put her on the radar of competition in the local volleyball scene.

Last fall, Hernandez played a pivotal role in helping the Jurupa Valley High girls’ volleyball team, affectionately known as the Lady Jags, reach the Southern Section Division 5 volleyball playoffs. However, her participation has now become a flashpoint for a larger debate, leading to three rival schools forfeiting previously scheduled nonleague volleyball matches against the Lady Jags this month.

Forfeits Spark Outrage

Most recently, Orange Vista High School in Perris made headlines by announcing it would not be attending the upcoming match against Jurupa Valley. This move followed in the footsteps of other schools, including Rim of the World High School and Riverside Poly High School, which also forfeited their games. These decisions are widely interpreted as a protest against Hernandez competing as a transgender athlete.

While some areas of the community support Hernandez’s right to compete, parents and one school board member at Riverside Poly High have explicitly confirmed that their forfeiting decision was connected to Hernandez’s participation on the opposing team. Rivals from other schools have remained tight-lipped about their choices, leaving many puzzled about the rationale behind their decisions.

Understanding the Rules

It’s important to note that California state law permits transgender females to compete in sports that align with their gender identity. Hernandez has taken full advantage of this supportive legislation, having competed in various sports for three years without any incidents. She openly identified as transgender during her eighth-grade year, though her name remained more on the low-key side until she was unfortunately outed by a former teacher on social media.

The controversy surrounding her participation in sports has gained national attention, to the extent that former President Trump threatened to withhold federal funding from the state over the issue. Adding fuel to the fire, the U.S. Justice Department has been advocating for California schools to prohibit transgender athletes from competition, which has stirred discussions about legal ramifications for schools that choose not to comply.

A Mom’s Perspective

Hernandez’s mother, Nereyda Hernandez, expressed her understanding of those opposed to her daughter’s participation and emphasized that AB views her peers simply as teammates and friends, regardless of the heated discussions swirling around the subject.

The spotlight on this issue raises questions regarding biological advantages in sports. Some coaches argue that athletes assigned male at birth often possess certain inherent benefits in aspects like coordination and strength when they compete against cisgender females. These assertions have been noted by those who question the fairness of mixed-gender competitions.

Future Matches for Lady Jags

As the situation stands, Jurupa Valley High School is working diligently to schedule more matches, ensuring its team can continue to compete. The upcoming game against Chaffey High School on September 4 has already been confirmed, allowing the Lady Jags the chance to showcase their skills in a competitive atmosphere.

As this situation unfolds, it’s clear that the discussion around transgender athletes in sports is far from over. In this friendly community, the complexities of fairness, equality, and representation are all being heavily examined, making this a topic to keep an eye on as it develops further.

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

LIVE BALL Resources

2025 High School Golf Season Launches in Wyoming
Controversy Erupts in California Volleyball Over Transgender Athlete
Gering Softball Team Launches Season with Victories
Gering High School Softball Kicks Off Season with Wins
Local High School Softball Teams Advance in State Tournaments
St. Paul Discusses Transgender Athletes in High School Softball
Minnesota Girls High School Tennis Welcomes Third Class
Transgender Athlete Sues Swarthmore College and NCAA
Transgender Woman Files Lawsuit Against NCAA and Swarthmore Over Exclusion from Women’s Track Team
Las Cruces Celebrates Fall Sports Media Day

Additional Resources