News Summary

Matt Ponatoski, a junior at Moeller High School in Sycamore Township, Ohio, has been named the Gatorade Ohio Baseball Player of the Year. This recognition follows his earlier accolade as Ohio’s Mr. Football, making him one of the few athletes in history to win state awards in two different sports in the same year. With impressive stats including a .462 batting average and 37 RBIs, Ponatoski continues to shine on the baseball diamond, leading his team to a successful season.

Matt Ponatoski of Moeller High School Named Gatorade Ohio Baseball Player of the Year

In the bustling city of Sycamore Township, Ohio, a young athlete is making headlines and capturing hearts! Matt Ponatoski, a junior at Moeller High School, has recently been honored with the prestigious Gatorade Ohio Baseball Player of the Year award. This exciting accolade marks his second Gatorade state award for the current school year, as he previously clinched the football award back in December 2024.

A Multi-talented Star

Matt is no ordinary high schooler; he’s a remarkable shortstop and pitcher on the baseball diamond, and when he’s not dazzling fans with his athletic prowess, he’s throwing touchdown passes as a four-star quarterback. To add to his impressive resume, he was also crowned Ohio’s Mr. Football in December 2024, making him one of the few athletes in history to win Gatorade state awards in two different team sports within the same academic year.

Joining an Elite Club

Let’s take a moment to appreciate how rare this achievement is. Only a select handful of athletes have managed to etch their names alongside legends like Joe Mauer from Minnesota (baseball and football) and Randy Moss from West Virginia (football and basketball). This places Ponatoski among the elite of elite!

A Stellar Baseball Season

On the baseball side, Matt continues to shine bright. He is currently recognized as the No. 1 high school baseball player in Ohio for his class by Prep Baseball Ohio. He also earned the title of co-player of the year in the Greater Catholic League (GCL) South division during the spring of 2025. With Moeller High School holding an impressive record of 24-3, they’re looking ahead to a thrilling matchup against Thomas Worthington in the Division I regional semifinal at Wright State University.

Stellar Stats and Future Prospects

As of early Tuesday afternoon, Ponatoski boasts some phenomenal baseball statistics: a dazzling .462 batting average, 37 RBIs, seven doubles, and four home runs. His on-base percentage stands at an impressive .556 over 27 games, and the future looks bright as he also received an invitation to the Elite 11 Finals, scheduled for June 17-19 at Mira Costa High School in Manhattan Beach, California.

Turning back to football, his performances last fall were nothing short of spectacular. He passed for over 4,000 yards and threw 56 touchdowns, all while keeping his interceptions down to just three. This remarkable showing has put him on the football recruiting map, ranking him as No. 100 overall and No. 9 among quarterbacks in the latest On300 football rankings.

College Choices on the Horizon

As he contemplates his bright athletic future, Ponatoski has honed in on four potential college options: Arkansas, Alabama, Oregon, and Kentucky. He’s gearing up for official visits, with Alabama on the calendar soon and Oregon planned for the weekend of June 20.

The Legacy of Gatorade Player of the Year Awards

The Gatorade Player of the Year awards have been honoring outstanding high school athletes since 1985. These awards not only spotlight athletic achievement but also highlight character and academic performance, making accolades like Matt’s even more special.

One thing is for sure: with records being broken and goals being met, Matt Ponatoski is not just another athlete. He’s a rising star who is well on his way to making his mark in the world of sports!

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

LIVE BALL Resources

Sioux Falls Honors 2025 Basketball Stars with Mr. and Miss Basketball Titles
Charlie Vause Wins National Boys Cross Country Player of the Year
Jarin Stevenson Joins UNC Basketball Team
Cleveland’s ‘A New Era Summit’ Promotes Girls Flag Football
Dee Alexander Signs with EZ Sports Group
Ohio High School Athletes to See Division Expansion in Track and Field & Cross Country
Ty Jones Makes History as Gatorade Player of the Year
Ohio Baseball Season Kicks Off with Preseason Rankings
Ohio High School Baseball Prepares for 2025 Season
Minneapolis High School Basketball Tournament Kicks Off

Additional Resources